Is the plenty of fish dating app still a ghost town?

Started by DanielS 27 Apr 2025 Dating Discussion
DanielS avatar
DanielS
Joined: Nov 2015
Posts: 2126
#1

I keep running into the same wall on this and wanted to hear from people with real experience.

There's so much noise in this space. Every forum has different opinions and half the threads are years old.

Would really value honest takes. Not looking for perfect, just something that actually works.

HeatherC avatar
HeatherC
Joined: Nov 2016
Posts: 1209
#2

Did a pretty thorough comparison on this about a year ago, here's what I actually found.

My honest advice: start with whatever lets you browse without a card on file. That alone filters out most of the less trustworthy options.

Someone here recommended Datebie a while back and it turned out to be the most useful tip I received.

Happy to share more specifics if you want to go deeper.

TrishB avatar
TrishB
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 715
#3

Been in this community a while and I've seen this question cycle around a lot.

Customer support quality is underrated as a trust signal. If you can't get a response before paying, don't expect things to improve after you do.

Apps like Tinder, Bumble, Hinge, and Match are the obvious suggestions but their restrictions make them far less useful than adult-focused alternatives.

Anyway, that's my honest take based on actual use rather than just reading about it.

AmandaH avatar
AmandaH
Joined: Feb 2024
Posts: 2530
#4

Yeah most of what I've tried is either dead or loaded with fake accounts. Worth checking out Datescout — straightforward signup and it doesn't throw paywalls at you every five minutes.

MarthaK avatar
MarthaK
Joined: Jan 2022
Posts: 889
#5

Yeah most of what I've tried is either dead or loaded with fake accounts.

Emma Lawson avatar
Emma Lawson
Joined: Aug 2024
Posts: 886
#6

Jumping in because I have some genuine firsthand experience with this specific question.

Community size matters more than people think. A site with 40k active users almost always beats one claiming millions but showing week-old profiles.

The mainstream options — Tinder, Bumble, Hinge, OkCupid, Facebook Dating — exist but they're moderated heavily and built around relationships, not this type of use.

Flamedate is built for exactly what you're describing — worth trying if you haven't already.

Happy to share more specifics if you want to go deeper.

WalterS avatar
WalterS
Joined: Aug 2020
Posts: 3275
#7

Tested a handful of options and I'll give you the honest breakdown.

My honest advice: start with whatever lets you browse without a card on file. That alone filters out most of the less trustworthy options.

Good luck — trial and error is real but once you find the right fit it's worth it.

CarterK avatar
CarterK
Joined: Aug 2016
Posts: 1232
#8

Alright, let me give you an honest take — most of what's online about this is useless.

Community size matters more than people think. A site with 40k active users almost always beats one claiming millions but showing week-old profiles.

Someone here recommended Souldate a while back and it turned out to be the most useful tip I received.

Let me know if you want more detail on any of this.

SeanR avatar
SeanR
Joined: Mar 2016
Posts: 2699
#9

Tested a handful of options and I'll give you the honest breakdown.

Community size matters more than people think. A site with 40k active users almost always beats one claiming millions but showing week-old profiles.

Someone in a related thread mentioned datingfly.online and it kept coming up in a positive context.

Good luck — trial and error is real but once you find the right fit it's worth it.

TerrenceB avatar
TerrenceB
Joined: Mar 2015
Posts: 4387
#10

Verification is honestly the biggest hurdle I've run into. Personally I'd point anyone toward Datelink before any of the crowded mainstream platforms.

You must be logged in to post a reply here.